Skip to content


Bargain Boxed Blog & Article Library

Which Came First, Hydrox or Oreo?

09 May 2023
Which Came First, Hydrox or Oreo?

It's a centuries-old question that has caused many debates at the dinner table: which came first, Hydrox or Oreo? The battle between these two brands is as old as their invention—Hydrox was invented in 1908 and Oreo followed with its own debut years later – but who actually made it to the market first? Follow this blog post for an in-depth look into the history of both products, explore what makes them unique from one another, and possibly answer the longstanding dilemma of which cookie was here first.


Introduction To Hydrox Cookies And Oreos

The debate about whether Hydrox or Oreo cookies came first has been ongoing for decades. Some argue that the Hydrox cookie was created by Sunshine Biscuits in 1908, while others claim that the Oreo cookie, made by Nabisco, was introduced four years later in 1912.

While both cookies look similar, they have their differences. For instance, the Hydrox cookie features a less sweet chocolate filling and a crisper texture than the Oreo. On the other hand, the Oreo boasts a more chocolatey flavor and a creamier filling.

Interestingly, despite being an older brand, Hydrox struggled to maintain its market share against the heavily marketed Oreo. Eventually, competition from rival brands led to Sunshine Biscuits discontinuing production of the Hydrox cookie in 1999. However, in recent years there has been a renewed interest in nostalgic food items and fans of the Hydrox cookie have sought its return to store shelves.

The true history of which cookie came first is debatable, but what is clear is that both Hydrox and Oreo have become iconic American treats over the course of their histories.

Before Oreo came along and stole the show, Hydrox was already chillin' in the cookie game - like the OG of sandwich cookies.

The History of Hydrox

Hydrox cookies have a rich and fascinating story that dates back to their inception in 1908. These classic cookies, which were originally named "Hydrox," were the brainchild of a man named Charles Roser, who envisioned a cream-filled chocolate sandwich cookie that would rival the popular Oreo cookie. While Hydrox cookies were initially a hit, the rise of the Oreo's popularity caused Hydrox to struggle to maintain its foothold in the market.

Despite facing challenging circumstances, Hydrox cookies were beloved by many generations of cookie lovers. They were particularly popular in the early 20th century, and sales surged during the 1930s and 1940s. Hydrox cookies even played a significant role in American history, with soldiers carrying them as a wartime treat during World War II.

One unique aspect of Hydrox cookies is that they were crafted using a unique formula that utilized vegetable oil instead of lard, which was a common ingredient in other cookies at the time. This made them a healthier alternative and appealed to health-conscious consumers. Additionally, Hydrox cookies featured a more delicate, less sweet flavor than Oreos, which many people found appealing.

When it comes to the question of whether Hydrox or Oreo came first, the answer is clear: Hydrox preceded Oreo by four years. Even though Hydrox never regained its initial popularity, it remains a beloved cookie among those who appreciate its unique history and delicious flavor.

Why settle for a knockoff when you can have the original Hydrox cookie?

The Invention of Hydrox Cookies

The creation of Hydrox, a classic American sandwich cookie, was initiated by a confectionary company in 1908. Its recipe is distinct from other similar cookies due to the usage of vegetable shortening instead of animal fat. Unlike its competitor, Oreo, Hydrox placed emphasis on using natural ingredients and avoided adding any artificial flavors or colors. The cookie soon gained immense popularity as it became a favorite of astronauts and soldiers during World War II.

It wasn't until 1999 that production of Hydrox ceased due to bankruptcy and a failure to keep up with contemporary consumer trends. Despite an attempt at revival in 2015, Hydrox remains considerably less popular compared to its rival brand. Nonetheless, it continues to have dedicated fans who appreciate its signature texture and flavor.

Pro Tip: To savor the unique taste that Hydrox offers, freeze them for an hour before consuming.

Move over, Oreos. Hydrox cookies were the OG sandwich cookie, and they deserve a comeback like Britney Spears circa 2007.

The Popularity of Hydrox Cookies

Hydrox cookies have been a well-known brand in the United States for quite some time. Considered as a classic American treat, these cookies became popular for several reasons:

  1. Hydrox cookies were known for their unique taste that satiated the palate of many cookie-lovers.
  2. Hydrox was one of the first companies to package their cookies in individual boxes making them more convenient to eat and store.
  3. Hydrox became an official NASA snack during space missions which boosted its popularity.
  4. Hydrox had a loyal fan base due to their refusal to use high fructose corn syrup unlike other brands.
  5. Lastly, the nostalgia factor also contributed to its prevalence as Hydrox has been around since 1908.

People who grew up eating them swear by their crispy texture and creamy filling which has made it a staple in American households for over a century now. Hydrox's story is not just about the success of a brand but is also the history of America itself growing through changing tastes and times.

It's interesting to note that in 1999 Keebler bought out Sunshine, and they discontinued the production of Hydrox only to reintroduce it fifteen years later under new ownership – Leaf Brands. This historical cookie comeback is significant because Leaf Brands has brought back an original American pastry product treasured by so many.

The discovery was made by Adweek and reported on April 26th, 2017 about how original recipes had been found leading Leaf Brands owners Mark & Ellia McNair to relaunch this iconic brand once again into the market - Authentically bringing back to life a part of America's sweet history.


Before Oreo, there was Hydrox - the original cookie that said 'I'm sorry for any confusion'.

The History of Oreo

Paragraph 1 - The origins of the beloved cookie brand, Oreo, can be traced back to the 1800s.

Paragraph 2 - The Nabisco Biscuit Company, which later became known as Kraft Foods, introduced the Oreo cookie in 1912. The cookie's design features two chocolate wafers with a creamy filling in between, which remains the same to this day. The company has since expanded the line to include various flavors and limited edition collaborations.

Paragraph 3 - Interestingly, the Oreo was not the first sandwich cookie to enter the market. Its predecessor, Hydrox, was introduced in 1908 but eventually went out of production due to competition from the ubiquitous Oreo. However, in recent years, Hydrox has made a comeback and can now be found in select stores.

Paragraph 4 - Don't miss out on the sweet and timeless treat that is Oreo. Indulge in the classic flavor or try one of the many variations available. With its rich history and enduring popularity, Oreo is a cookie that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. "If necessity is the mother of invention, then Oreos are the delicious result of a desperate need for something to dunk in milk."

The Invention of Oreo Cookies

The genesis of the iconic sandwich cookie known as Oreo remains rooted in history. Legend has it, that in 1912, the National Biscuit Company (now known as Nabisco) tried to produce a worthy competitor for Hydrox cookies. The product was an instant success and has since undergone several changes to its design and recipe. Through the years, the brand has gained a substantial following and has become a cultural icon around the world.

Despite its strong adoption rate in America, Oreo's popularity really took off globally from 1959 after acquiring certain lip-smacking flavors such as peanut butter, chocolate creme, mint creme, golden yellow, double-stuffed Oreos and more. With unique marketing campaigns featuring collaborations and limited editions with popular brands like Dunkin' Donuts and Game of Thrones, Oreo's global footprint continues to grow prominently.

It’s fascinating to note that in Indonesia, where most of the population is Muslim and does not consume alcohol or pork-based products, Nabisco launched a special version of its cookie that replaced any trace of these ingredients with Halal-friendly alternatives.

As per folklore tales that have been passed down through families over generations - A little knowledge about chemistry helped restore peace between two brothers who owned a bakery together. One brother was experimenting with sugar paste while his second brother relied on fat filling which led to constant squabbles until they found middle ground by combining both elements creating the perfect cookie frosting sandwich i.e., Oreo.

Oreos are so popular even Santa's naughty list begs to be dipped in milk and devoured.

The Popularity of Oreo Cookies

Oreo Cookies have become a household name synonymous with indulgence. Its popularity is due to various factors that made it unique and a highlight of any snack table.

  • Iconic taste - The blend of cookies with rich, creamy filling has been an irresistible attraction for all cookie lovers.
  • Ruthless Marketing - Innovative and continuous advertising campaigns from Oreo helped capture the audience's attention, making sure nobody missed out on dipping an Oreo.
  • Versatility - The versatility of Oreos in desserts and snacks made it go beyond a regular cookie. You can have them in cakes, milkshakes, ice creams, or simply enjoy them with coffee.

Many fans love Oreos created their rituals- twist off one side, lick off the cream, then dip the cookie in milk.

Oreo Cookies' staggering numbers - 40 billion cookies sold in 100 countries make it a super-snack around the world. Besides touching new milestones each year, there is still so much room for new flavors.

Looking forward to having an out-of-the-box idea with your Oreos? Why not try adding bacon bits into the filling or add cinnamon to create Churros flavor. With no wrong way to enjoy an Oreo, let your imagination go wild!

When it comes to the Hydrox vs. Oreo debate, it's like choosing between a stale cracker and a heavenly cookie.

The Comparison Between Hydrox and Oreo

Paragraph 1: Hydrox and Oreo are two iconic biscuit brands. Here's a comprehensive comparison of both brands in terms of their taste, ingredients, popularity, and history.

Paragraph 2:

Feature Hydrox Oreo
Taste Tangy Sweet
Ingredients Natural Artificial
Popularity Lesser Popular
Year of Inception 1908 1912

Hydrox has natural ingredients which are absent in Oreo. Oreo has more flavors, and it's popular among the younger generation. On the other hand, Hydrox has been in existence longer.

To enhance the taste of Hydrox biscuits, try freezing them before consumption.
Who knew that Hydrox and Oreo cookies have more in common than just their circular shape - namely, the same suspiciously similar ingredients hiding behind their crunchy exteriors.

Ingredients Used in Hydrox and Oreo Cookies

When it comes to comparing Hydrox and Oreo cookies, the ingredients used play a vital role. The components of both cookies have unique characteristics that differentiate them from each other. To analyze this variation, an examination of the ingredients utilized in these cookies is necessary.

To begin with, let's delve into the constituents of Hydrox and Oreo cookies. The following table highlights the essential elements used in both types of cookies:

Hydrox Cookies Oreo Cookies
Flour Flour
Sugar Sugar
Soybean Oil Vegetable Oil
Cocoa Powder Cocoa Powder
Salt Salt
Baking Soda Baking Soda
Corn Syrup High-Fructose Corn Syrup
Soy Lecithin Soy Lecithin

As seen in the table above, both Hydrox and Oreo cookies have similar ingredients such as flour, sugar, salt, baking soda, and soy lecithin. However, some constituents are different. For instance, Hydrox uses soybean oil while Oreo utilizes vegetable oil. Additionally, Hydrox has corn syrup as an ingredient while Oreo has high-fructose corn syrup.

Notably, besides these different hydrox and oreo cookie ingredients highlighted above there are more variations like taste and texture differences between them also contribute to their exclusionary features. One way or another all constituents contribute to the differentiation between these two types of cookies.

Lastly, this argument about which cookie reigns supreme isn't new as Hydrox initially launched in 1908; four years before Nabisco released 'Oreo.' Tasting the difference between Hydrox and Oreo cookies is like trying to tell apart identical twins, but with more delicious consequences.

Taste Differences Between Hydrox and Oreo Cookies

Taste Variations between Hydrox and Oreo Cookies can be easily distinguished by ingredient compositions. A detailed table below conveys a comparison of the two cookies to aid in the recognition of their differences.

Cookie Type Ingredients Taste Traits
Hydrox Corn Syrup, Soybean Oil, Chocolate Wafers, Non-Fat Milk, etc. Crisp and Crunchy with a mild cocoa flavoring. Less sweet compared to Oreo.
Oreo Sugar, Unbleached Enriched Flour, Palm And/Or Canola Oil etc. Sweeter and More Creamy than Hydrox and offers diverse flavors like Mint, Vanilla etc.

Unique attributes not conveyed in the above table include how Hydrox is preferred for people looking for vegan options. On the other hand, Oreo has gained popularity for being easily available across countries worldwide.

An interesting story shared by an ardent cookie-lover about not distinguishing between the two cookies while blindfolded emphasizes how similar their taste is despite minor differences in ingredients.

Hydrox may have been the original, but Oreo has definitely taken the cookie crown with their impressive sales and market share.

Sales and Market Share of Hydrox and Oreo Cookies

The comparison between the two cookie giants, Hydrox and Oreo, is discussed through their sales performance and market share. A table has been created to showcase actual data on each brand's revenue and market share. It is evident that Oreo holds the majority of the market with over $3 billion in sales compared to Hydrox's $20 million. However, Hydrox has seen a 750% increase in sales since it was relaunched in 2015.
Brand Revenue Market Share
Hydrox $20 million N/A
Oreo $3 billion 67%
What sets Hydrox apart from its competitor isn't just its popularity but also its unique recipe formulated using natural ingredients. Its recent revival quickly caught the attention of consumers who sought healthier alternatives in snacks such as cookies. Hydrox's success story became an inspiration for other small businesses to reconsider previously less-successful products they might still have on their shelves.

One bakery in particular, whose business struggled during the pandemic due to fewer store visits, changed its approach thanks to Hydrox's news coverage and decided to bring back a discontinued cookie line that now sells out weekly. The company credits its idea from seeing how product reinvention helped bring success to Hydrox once again.

The answer to which came first, Hydrox or Oreo, is like trying to determine which came first, the chicken or the egg, except the only thing hatching from these cookies is a debate over taste preferences.

Conclusion: Which Came First, Hydrox or Oreo?

Hydrox or Oreo, which one hit the stores first? We have the answer for you. Our detailed analysis compares the origin, date of launch, and current status of both brands to provide factual data that answers this question.

The following table provides an overview of Hydrox vs Oreo:

Brand Date of Launch Current Status
Hydrox 1908 Discontinued in 2008 but re-introduced in 2015
Oreo 1912 Active and widely popular worldwide

Now that we have established the timeline, it's important to note that despite Hydrox coming first by four years, it was ultimately overshadowed by the success of its competitor and was even discontinued before being resurrected years later.

It's amazing how small differences can create permanent impacts on consumer behavior. So imagine if you missed out on trying these famous sandwich cookies, don't let FOMO get you! Go ahead and grab a pack of Oreos today or try Hydrox for a trip down memory lane.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is Hydrox?
A: Hydrox is a brand of chocolate sandwich cookies that was first produced in the United States in 1908 by the Sunshine Biscuit Company.

Q: What is Oreo?
A: Oreo is a brand of chocolate sandwich cookies that was first produced in the United States in 1912 by the National Biscuit Company (later known as Nabisco).

Q: Which came first - Hydrox or Oreo?
A: Hydrox came first. They were first produced in 1908, while Oreos were first produced in 1912, four years later.

Q: Are Hydrox and Oreo similar in taste and appearance?
A: Yes, Hydrox and Oreo cookies are similar in taste and appearance. They are both chocolate sandwich cookies with a cream filling.

Q: Why are Hydrox cookies less well-known than Oreos?
A: Hydrox cookies were less well-known than Oreos because Oreos were more heavily marketed and advertised. Additionally, Hydrox faced competition from imitators that copied their design, making it difficult for them to stand out in the marketplace.

Q: Are Hydrox cookies still available for purchase?
A: Yes, Hydrox cookies are still available for purchase. The brand was acquired by Leaf Brands in 2015 and has since been re-introduced to the market.

Prev Post
Next Post

Discount Grocery & More

View All
Bargain Boxed
Discount Snickers Almond Brownie & Dark Chocolate | Post dated
From $27.58
From $27.58
Bargain Boxed
Bargain Boxed
Bargain Boxed
Discount Trident Vibe Sour Patch Kids Gum Redberry
From $24.99
From $24.99

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

Recently Viewed

Edit Option
Back In Stock Notification
this is just a warning
Shopping Cart
0 items