Skip to content

contact@bargainboxed,com

Are Discount Grocery Stores Worth It? What You NEED To Know

16 Apr 2025
Are Discount Grocery Stores Worth It? What You NEED To Know and grocery items in a shopping cart

Are Discount Grocery Stores Worth It? What Experts Won't Tell You

What's in This Article

  • Why Discount Grocery Stores Are Growing in Popularity
  • How Much Can You Actually Save?
  • Types of Discount Grocery Stores Explained
  • When 'Best By' Dates Don't Matter (And When They Do)
  • Quality Comparison: Discount vs. Traditional Stores
  • Hidden Costs to Consider
  • Smart Shopping Strategies for Maximum Savings
  • Who Benefits Most from Discount Grocery Shopping
  • Myths and Facts About Discount Grocery Items
  • FAQs About Discount Grocery Stores

Quick Answer

Discount grocery stores are definitely worth it for budget-conscious shoppers, offering savings of 30-50% compared to traditional supermarkets. While you may sacrifice some brand selection and shopping amenities, the quality of most products remains comparable, particularly for shelf-stable items. Understanding product dating practices and shopping strategically can maximize your savings without compromising on quality.

Why Discount Grocery Stores Are Growing in Popularity

In today's economy, discount grocery stores have seen unprecedented growth as shoppers seek relief from rising food costs. Recent consumer data shows that discount grocery shopping has increased by over 35% in the past three years, with no signs of slowing down.

Discount grocery stores like Bargain Boxed offer significantly lower prices by operating on different business models than traditional supermarkets. By reducing overhead costs, purchasing overstock or closeout items, and streamlining operations, these retailers pass substantial savings to consumers.

The typical discount grocery store provides savings between 30-50% on many everyday items. For a family spending $800 monthly on groceries, switching to discount stores could translate to annual savings of $2,400-$4,800 – enough for a vacation or significant contribution to emergency savings.

How Much Can You Actually Save?

The savings at discount grocery stores vary by product category, but are most substantial in these areas:

Shelf-Stable Products

Packaged foods like pasta, rice, canned goods, and snacks often see the deepest discounts, ranging from 40-60% off regular retail prices. These items typically have long shelf lives, making them ideal discount grocery purchases.

Household Items

Paper products, cleaning supplies, and personal care items frequently cost 30-45% less at discount grocery outlets compared to traditional stores.

Specialty Foods

Gourmet and specialty items that typically command premium prices elsewhere can be found at discount grocers for 50-70% less, though selection varies based on available inventory.

A recent comparison shopping study found that a basket of 30 common grocery items cost $127 at a traditional supermarket versus just $76 at discount grocery stores – a 40% savings that adds up substantially over time.

Types of Discount Grocery Stores Explained

Not all discount grocery retailers operate the same way. Understanding the different types can help you choose where to shop:

Closeout Grocery Stores

Retailers like Bargain Boxed specialize in selling overstock, discontinued items, or products approaching their best-by dates at deep discounts. These stores offer constantly changing inventory with some of the deepest discounts available.

Discount Chains

Stores like Aldi and Lidl operate on a low-overhead model with limited selection but consistent pricing that's typically 25-40% lower than traditional supermarkets.

Salvage Grocery Stores

These sell items with packaging imperfections, seasonal overruns, or products that didn't meet manufacturer specifications despite being perfectly safe and edible.

Warehouse Clubs

While requiring membership fees, stores like Costco and Sam's Club offer bulk purchasing options that can provide significant savings for larger households.

When 'Best By' Dates Don't Matter (And When They Do)

One of the biggest misconceptions keeping shoppers from discount grocery stores involves confusion about product dating. Here's what experts won't always tell you:

Shelf-Stable Foods

Most packaged, canned, and dry goods remain perfectly safe and retain quality for months or even years past their 'best by' dates when stored properly. These dates indicate peak quality periods rather than safety cutoffs. Items like rice, pasta, canned vegetables, and many snack foods can be consumed long after their suggested dates with no noticeable difference in taste or quality.

Understanding Date Labels

The USDA confirms that date labels like 'best by,' 'sell by,' and 'use by' are manufacturer suggestions for peak quality, not safety indicators (except for infant formula). Many foods remain safe and nutritious well beyond these dates.

Safe Storage Practices

Proper storage significantly extends the usable life of many products. Keep dry goods in cool, dry places away from direct sunlight, ensure canned goods aren't dented or bulging, and use common sense—check for off odors or appearance changes before consumption.

When Dates Do Matter

Exercise more caution with refrigerated items like dairy, meat, and prepared foods, which have stricter safety windows. However, many discount grocers don't sell these perishable items, focusing instead on shelf-stable products.

Quality Comparison: Discount vs. Traditional Stores

The perception that discount groceries mean lower quality is largely unfounded. Consider these quality comparisons:

Brand Name Products

Many discount grocery stores sell the exact same name-brand products found in traditional supermarkets, just at lower prices due to overstock, packaging changes, or approaching best-by dates.

Packaging Differences

Sometimes the only difference is cosmetic—dented cans, updated packaging designs, or seasonal packaging that's no longer current. The contents remain identical to full-price versions.

Blind Taste Tests

Consumer studies consistently show that in blind taste tests, participants rarely identify differences between discount grocery items and their full-price counterparts, particularly with packaged foods.

Manufacturing Standards

All food sold in the United States, regardless of where it's sold, must meet the same FDA safety standards. Discount doesn't mean lower safety requirements.

Hidden Costs to Consider

While the savings at discount grocery stores are substantial, there are potential additional costs to factor in:

Shopping Strategy Required

The inconsistent inventory at some discount grocers may necessitate visits to multiple stores to complete your shopping list, potentially increasing transportation costs.

Limited Return Options

Many discount grocers, including Bargain Boxed, have final sale policies to keep prices low, meaning you can't return items you're unsatisfied with.

Quantity Management

The temptation to stock up on deeply discounted items can lead to food waste if you purchase more than you can reasonably consume before quality deterioration.

Potential Travel Distance

Some discount grocery outlets aren't as conveniently located as mainstream supermarkets, potentially adding transportation costs.

Woman holding groceries in a basket in a discount grocery store

Smart Shopping Strategies for Maximum Savings

Maximize your discount grocery experience with these expert strategies:

Inventory Assessment First

Before shopping, take inventory of what you already have to avoid unnecessary purchases, especially important with varying discount store inventory.

Flexible Meal Planning

Rather than rigid meal plans, develop flexible meal ideas that can accommodate various ingredients based on what's available at discount prices.

Storage Solutions

Invest in quality storage containers to maintain freshness of bulk purchases. Consider vacuum sealers for extending shelf life of applicable products.

Calculate True Value

Don't just look at the price—calculate the price per ounce or unit to ensure you're getting a genuine bargain compared to sales at traditional stores.

Buy What You'll Use

Even at 80% off, a product isn't a good deal if it goes unused. Be realistic about your consumption habits when purchasing unfamiliar items.

Who Benefits Most from Discount Grocery Shopping

While anyone can benefit from grocery savings, certain groups see particularly strong advantages:

Large Families

Households feeding many people see exponential savings when cutting grocery costs by 30-50%.

Budget-Conscious Consumers

Those working within strict financial constraints can significantly stretch their food dollars without sacrificing nutrition.

Non-Profit Organizations

Community groups providing food assistance can serve more people by sourcing from discount grocers.

Bulk Purchasers

Those with storage space who can buy larger quantities of non-perishable items maximize savings over time.

Flexible Shoppers

People who aren't brand-loyal and can adapt to varying inventory find the most consistent savings.

Myths and Facts About Discount Grocery Items

Let's clear up some common misconceptions:

Myth: Discount groceries are nearly expired or unsafe

Fact: Most discount groceries are perfectly safe and often far from their actual spoilage date. Shelf-stable items typically remain good for months or years beyond best-by dates when stored properly.

Myth: Only low-quality brands are sold at discount stores

Fact: Many discount grocers sell the same national brands found in traditional supermarkets, just at lower prices due to purchasing strategies.

Myth: The selection is only unhealthy processed foods

Fact: While inventory varies, many discount grocers offer healthy options including whole grains, beans, nuts, and other nutritious staples.

Myth: The savings aren't worth the shopping experience

Fact: For most households, the 30-50% savings far outweigh the potential inconveniences of varied selection or simpler store layouts.

Myth: You need memberships or special qualifications

Fact: Most discount grocery stores, including Bargain Boxed, are open to everyone with no membership fees or special requirements.

FAQs About Discount Grocery Stores

Q: Are products at discount grocery stores safe to eat? A: Yes, all food sold at discount grocery stores must meet the same FDA safety standards as traditional supermarkets. Always use common sense and check for signs of spoilage regardless of where you shop.

Q: Why are prices so much lower at discount grocery stores? A: Discount grocery stores obtain products through overstock purchases, closeouts, packaging changes, or items approaching (but not past) best-by dates. Lower overhead costs and streamlined operations also contribute to savings.

Q: Can I find organic or specialty diet foods at discount grocers? A: Many discount grocery stores do offer organic, gluten-free, and other specialty items, though selection varies based on available inventory. Bargain Boxed and similar retailers often have these items at significant discounts.

Q: How often does inventory change at discount grocery stores? A: Inventory at many discount grocers changes frequently—sometimes weekly or even daily—as new overstock and closeout deals become available. This creates a 'treasure hunt' shopping experience where regular visits reveal new savings opportunities.

Q: Are discount groceries just items other stores couldn't sell? A: Not typically. Most discount grocery items are regular retail products that became available through overproduction, packaging changes, warehouse clearouts, or seasonal turnover—not quality issues.

Q: Can I save on all my grocery needs at discount stores? A: While discount grocery stores offer substantial savings on many items, most specialize in shelf-stable products. For comprehensive grocery needs, many shoppers combine discount store shopping with selective traditional store purchases.

Q: How do discount grocers like Bargain Boxed keep prices so low? A: Bargain Boxed and similar retailers maintain low prices through strategic purchasing of closeouts and overstock, minimal advertising, streamlined operations, no-return policies, and efficient inventory management.

Conclusion: Are Discount Grocery Stores Really Worth It?

The evidence overwhelmingly suggests that discount grocery stores offer genuine value for most shoppers. With potential savings of 30-50% on grocery staples, the financial benefits are substantial—potentially thousands of dollars annually for the average family.

While discount grocery shopping may require more flexibility and strategic planning than traditional supermarket visits, the trade-offs are well worth it for budget-conscious consumers. Understanding that most shelf-stable products remain perfectly good well beyond their best-by dates opens up significant saving opportunities without compromising quality or safety.

For maximum benefit, consider incorporating discount grocery stores like Bargain Boxed into your regular shopping routine, particularly for shelf-stable pantry staples, household items, and specialty products where the savings are most dramatic. With smart shopping strategies and a flexible approach to meal planning, discount grocery stores can dramatically reduce your food budget while maintaining quality and variety.

The bottom line: discount grocery stores aren't just worth it—they're an untapped resource that more savvy shoppers should be utilizing to combat rising food costs while maintaining quality nutrition.

Prev Post
Next Post

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose Options

Edit Option
Back In Stock Notification
this is just a warning
Login
Shopping Cart
0 items