Best Food Storage Containers According to Consumer Reports: Complete Guide

In this comprehensive guide, we're diving deep into the world of food storage containers to bring you the best options according to Consumer Reports testing. Whether you're meal prepping, storing leftovers, or organizing your pantry, having the right containers can make all the difference. At Bargain Boxed, we're committed to helping you find quality storage solutions at unbeatable prices.

What's in This Article:

• Top-rated food storage containers based on Consumer Reports
• Key features to look for when purchasing food storage containers
• Glass vs. plastic container comparison
• Best containers for different storage needs
• Care and maintenance tips
• Frequently asked questions

Quick Answer: Best Food Storage Containers

Consumer Reports rates the following as top performers:

• Best Overall: Pyrex Simply Store Glass Food Storage Set
• Best Budget Option: Rubbermaid Brilliance Food Storage Containers
• Best for Meal Prep: Prep Naturals Glass Meal Prep Containers
• Most Durable: OXO Good Grips Smart Seal
• Best Eco-Friendly: Stasher Silicone Reusable Food Bags

At Bargain Boxed, we offer these top-performing brands at prices lower than anywhere else online, no membership required!

What Makes a Great Food Storage Container?

According to Consumer Reports testing, the best food storage containers share several important qualities:

Airtight Seals

Containers that keep air out preserve food freshness longer and prevent leaks. Silicone gaskets and locking mechanisms provide the best seal performance.

Durability

High-quality containers withstand repeated use, cleaning, temperature changes, and the occasional drop without cracking or warping.

Stain and Odor Resistance

Nobody wants containers that hold onto yesterday's spaghetti sauce smell. The best containers resist both stains and odors.

Stackability

Space-saving design is crucial for organized refrigerators and pantries. Containers that nest when empty and stack securely when full earn top marks.

Versatility

Top performers can go from freezer to microwave to dishwasher safely, making them more convenient and practical for everyday use.

Glass vs. Plastic: The Great Container Debate

Consumer Reports testing consistently shows advantages and disadvantages to both materials:

Glass Containers

Pros:

• Completely stain and odor resistant
• Can be used in conventional ovens
• More environmentally friendly
• Perceived as healthier option
• Glass doesn't degrade over time

Cons:

• Heavier and more breakable
• Generally more expensive
• Takes up more storage space

Plastic Containers

Pros:

• Lightweight and less breakable
• Usually less expensive
• Often more stackable and space-efficient

Cons:

• Can absorb stains and odors
• May contain chemicals (look for BPA-free)
• Can warp or crack with temperature changes
• May degrade faster with repeated use

At Bargain Boxed, we offer both premium glass and high-quality plastic options so you can choose what works best for your lifestyle needs.

Top Food Storage Containers According to Consumer Reports

1. Pyrex Simply Store Glass Food Storage Set

Consumer Reports ranks Pyrex tops for temperature resistance, stain prevention, and durability. The colorful lids make organizing easy, and the glass bases go seamlessly from freezer to oven. While glass is heavier than plastic alternatives, the quality and durability make this set worth the investment.

2. Rubbermaid Brilliance Food Storage Containers

These crystal-clear plastic containers feature leakproof lids with vents for splatter-free microwave heating. Consumer Reports gives them high marks for stackability and seal performance. The containers resist stains better than most plastic options and are BPA-free.

3. OXO Good Grips Smart Seal

Consumer Reports praises these containers for their exceptional airtight seal and modular design that maximizes storage space. The push-button lids create an airtight seal with one simple touch, and the containers stack perfectly for organized storage.

4. Glasslock Oven Safe Container Set

These tempered glass containers score exceptionally well in drop tests and thermal shock resistance. The four-sided locking lids prevent leaks and keep food fresh longer, according to Consumer Reports testing.

5. Snapware Total Solution Pyrex Glass

Combining Pyrex glass with innovative lids, these containers earn top marks for versatility and durability. The written-date feature allows you to track when food was stored - particularly helpful when properly stored foods can last well beyond best-by dates.

Best Containers for Different Storage Needs

Best for Meal Prep

Prep Naturals Glass Meal Prep Containers feature portion-controlled compartments that keep foods separate. Consumer Reports notes their durability and excellent seal performance, making them ideal for weekly meal preparation.

Best for Dry Goods

OXO POP Containers receive high ratings for their airtight seals that keep pantry staples fresh. The modular design maximizes shelf space, and the push-button mechanism creates an airtight seal with one touch.

Best for Leftovers

Pyrex Simply Store containers work exceptionally well for leftovers, as they go from refrigerator to microwave or oven seamlessly. Their non-porous glass won't absorb food odors, flavors, or stains.

Best for Freezer Storage

Glasslock containers perform excellently in extreme temperature tests, making them ideal for freezer use. Their tight seals prevent freezer burn, and the tempered glass resists thermal shock when transferring from freezer to microwave.

Care and Maintenance Tips

Consumer Reports testing reveals that proper care significantly extends container lifespan:

• Allow hot food to cool before sealing to prevent condensation
• Hand wash lids with gaskets to preserve seal integrity
• Remove gaskets for thorough cleaning when needed
• Store containers with lids off or loosely attached
• Check plastic containers regularly for signs of degradation

When properly maintained, quality food storage containers can safely preserve your food for years. This is especially important when storing foods that remain perfectly usable past their best-by date, such as many shelf-stable pantry items when stored in airtight containers.

Are Food Storage Containers Worth the Investment?

According to Consumer Reports, investing in high-quality storage containers offers several benefits:

• Reduces food waste by keeping food fresh longer
• Decreases reliance on single-use containers
• Makes meal preparation more efficient
• Organizes refrigerator and pantry spaces
• Saves money over time

At Bargain Boxed, we believe offering premium storage containers at unbeatable prices makes this investment even more worthwhile. Our ever-revolving inventory means we can offer significant savings on top brands without requiring memberships or subscriptions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do food storage containers typically last?

High-quality glass containers can last decades with proper care. Premium plastic containers typically last 3-5 years before showing signs of wear.

Are plastic containers safe?

Consumer Reports recommends choosing BPA-free containers and replacing any that show signs of degradation like cracks or severe discoloration. Look for containers labeled specifically as food-safe.

Can all containers go in the microwave?

No. Glass containers generally perform well in microwaves, but plastic varies. Check manufacturer guidelines and look for microwave-safe labeling. Even with microwave-safe containers, Consumer Reports recommends venting lids to prevent pressure buildup.

How can I prevent staining in plastic containers?

Spray containers with cooking spray before storing tomato-based foods, avoid microwaving saucy foods in plastic, and clean containers promptly after use.

Are more expensive containers worth it?

Consumer Reports testing indicates a strong correlation between price and performance, particularly for durability and seal quality. However, mid-range options often perform comparably to premium brands, offering excellent value.

How do I know if my containers are still good to use?

Replace containers with cracks, warping, or severe staining. For plastic containers, replace any that have become very flexible or brittle. Glass containers should be replaced if they chip or crack.

What's the best way to organize food storage containers?

Store containers with similar sizes nested together. Store lids vertically in a dedicated organizer or large container. Keep frequently used containers in easily accessible locations.

Conclusion

Investing in quality food storage containers pays dividends in food freshness, kitchen organization, and reducing waste. Consumer Reports testing consistently shows that features like airtight seals, durability, and versatility make certain brands stand out from the competition.

At Bargain Boxed, we pride ourselves on offering these top-performing brands at prices lower than anywhere else online. Our no-membership, no-frills approach allows us to pass tremendous savings directly to you. While we keep our prices low by offering all sales as final, we ensure you have the information needed to make smart purchasing decisions.

Whether you prefer glass for its durability and eco-friendliness or opt for lightweight plastic for convenience, proper food storage containers are an essential kitchen investment that quickly pays for itself in reduced food waste and improved organization.